Oceans in trouble as acid levels rise
Published online: 30 June 2005
http://www.nature.com/news/2005/0506...050627-14.html

Oceans in trouble as acid levels rise
Michael Hopkin
Report calls for more stringent carbon cuts to protect seas.

Corals and plankton are at risk of being destroyed by the rising acidity of
the world's oceans as the waters absorb carbon dioxide from the air, British
scientists have warned. The only solution, they say, is drastic cuts in
carbon dioxide emissions, far beyond those called for by the Kyoto treaty.

Without such measures, dissolved carbon dioxide could increase the acidity
of sea water by as much as 0.5 pH units by the end of this century, from 8.2
to around 7.7, they say. Such a change would upset the oceans' chemical
balance and kill off some marine life.

"There is no way for us to remove this CO2 from the ocean. It will take many
thousands of years for natural processes to remove it," said lead author
John Raven of the University of Dundee, at the report's launch in London. As
long as we keep putting carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, he added, it
will keep finding its way into the ocean. As carbon dioxide dissolves in
water it forms weak carbonic acid, which can dissolve materials such as
shells and coral.

Since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution, humans have pumped an
estimated total of 450 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere,
around half of which has ended up in the oceans, Raven said. He and his
colleagues are calling for no more than 900 billion tonnes to be added
during this century - a tall order given the burgeoning industrial
development of China and India.

This target would call for huge cuts, with emissions by 2100 reaching half
their present levels. This is far in excess of the more modest targets set
by the Kyoto treaty, which calls for developed nations to cut their
emissions, relative to 1990 levels, by an average of 5% by 2012.

Hot water

Without action to combat acidification, the effects are likely to be
strongest in the Southern Ocean around Antarctica, the report says1. Tiny
shell-forming molluscs called pteropods live here and help form the basis of
Antarctic food chains, says Carol Turley of the Plymouth Marine Laboratory.
"This is another very strong argument for reducing carbon dioxide
emissions," she adds.

Other potential victims would be coccolithophores, tiny hard-shelled
plankton that can blossom in huge numbers, forming swarms visible from
space.

And while corals face bleaching and death from higher-temperature waters,
the report's authors note that acidic waters are a big problem too. They
calculate that even under the lowest future scenarios for carbon emissions
produced by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, corals such as
those on Australia's Great Barrier Reef could be all but wiped out by 2050
by acidity.

There are a few theoretical quick fixes for ocean acidification, such as
dumping limestone into the water to boost mineral levels and buffer the
ability of carbon dioxide to change the pH. But we would have to dig up 60
square kilometres of chalk to a depth of 100 metres every year to provide
enough, notes study author Andrew Watson of the University of East Anglia in
Norwich. This is unfeasible and risks causing further damage to the planet,
he adds.

The only answer is to stop burning so much fossil fuel, Watson says. "We are
addicted to fossil-fuel burning like a smoker is addicted to nicotine," he
says. "Like smoking, there are many adverse effects - we need to wake up and
heed the doctor's orders."

References
Royal Society Working Group on Ocean Acidification.
Ocean Acidification Due to Increasing Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide. (2005).

James Chamblee <jim-chamblee@mindspring.com> wrote in
news:BEEB2DF9.4AE9%jim-chamblee@mindspring.com:

I really do wish that the GW fanatics could make up their minds.

First we hear about how the rising temperatures are driving all
the CO2 out of the water and threatening the air.

Now we have the oceans removing massive abouts of CO2 from the
air and threatening to kill everything.

MAKE UP YOU MINDS AND STICK TO ONE STORY

Earl wrote:
You are the source that claims that the CO2 is coming from the
ocean, i.e. the Indian Ocean bit of the thermohaline circulation IIRC.
Go ahead and make up your mind.

Earl at neptune@wt.net wrote

You poor uneducated Righties always make life so difficult for yourselves,
with a "one size fits all" mentality.

This piece didn't say anything about "threatening to kill everything" as you
claimed. It talked about coral and plankton only.

The oceans are not monolithic, although I suppose that the Right Wing
assumes that they are. If you examine wind, current, salinity and ocean
temperature charts, you will discover that the oceans support hundreds of
different ecosystems around the globe. The Gulf Stream alone supports a
number of ecosystems, including palm trees growing in Ireland.

Plankton and coral reefs are more impacted by acid levels than other life.
Scientists have for several years realized that coral reefs were shrinking.
Now they apparently know why.`

Please try to keep up.